Now that we've gotten rid of the panty-waists, onward!
In 1981, Superman II was unleashed upon an unsuspecting America. This movie was so terrible, I swore off hero movies in the theater until the first Burton Batman years later (I saw III on rental and still haven't seen IV). And, this movie has always occupied a special benchmark in my heart. Superman II is the movie I compare all terrible comic movies to- in terms of departure from themes, cannon, and concepts.
And, the only movie to actually be worse is the Dolph Lundgren Punisher. I mean, riding a Harley in the sewers while fighting Ninjas. Seriously?!?
But, I digress.
One of the reasons this movie blows chunks- the producers fired Richard Donner 75% of the way through filming and replaced him with Richard Lester. And, Lester himself stated that he had no idea who or what Superman was when he took over the job after Donner was fired.
You know, I have to wonder about the wisdom of hiring a guy that knows zero about the main character. Not what I would call an A-list move.
Then a friend of mine mentioned that Superman II had been recut, and restored using the unfinished Donner footage to complete the movie the way it had been originally intended- a direct sequel to the original. And, I was not exactly sure why I should care about it.
Let's not discuss how I got to watching this movie. Let's just discuss that after viewing it I can tell you that this movie is vastly superior to the theatrical release in exactly three ways.
- No taffy-pull S shield move in the Fortress.
- No “here I am! Tee-hee, no I'm not!” illusion moves.
- No Super Kiss.
And, those three things make this movie astronomically better than what was originally released, and even take it out of the “eh” range and into the “not too bad!” range.
Don't get me wrong, there are still some unanswered questions like how do the three Kryptonians understand and speak English, exactly how did human Clark and Lois leave the Fortress since they flew there, and why did Superman kill the last three Kryptonians (keep in mind part of the cannon is the Big Blue doesn't kill) instead of saving their lives. And, frankly, I could go on. So, there are a lot of things about this movie that are still really sloppy, and it could have used a few re-writes to clean them up.
Which is why it's “not too bad” and not higher up on the chain.
Oh- and a bit of a spoiler ahead so stop reading now if you don't want to know more:
Lois figures out Clark is Superman in the first 5 minutes of the film. Which, I feel is a lot better. How they deal with it is good, and makes sense. Also, did I mention no Super Kiss that makes her forget?
Well, they still have to separate at the end, and while there is no Super Kiss the resolution isn't all that much better. Supes does the lame time rewind thing again and resets the world. Although, it doesn't show what he does different to save the world, only that he rewound it to before Zod and minions show up.
So, there's that too.
But, in comparison to what came before?
At least three times better.

